Memberful vs CircleIs an all-in-one platform the best fit for your community?
Should you build your memberships on Memberful or Circle?
Comparing Memberful and Circle for Community-Driven Businesses
Your member experience should reflect your community values and your vision for your business. Memberful and Circle offer two distinct paths to building memberships that fit both.
What is Memberful?
Memberful is a membership platform that gives you total ownership of your business. You control your branding, your data, your payments, and your subscriptions.
It’s a natural fit for content-forward creators. With Memberful, you can add exclusive content to your WordPress site, share private podcasts, or send member newsletters, with Discord and Discourse integrations ready to add a community space to the mix.
What is Circle?
If community is your business’ core focus, Circle is an all-in-one platform to create a hub for member connection. Known for its many features and sleek UX, it's a great choice for creators who want a solid community platform without integrating other tools or spending too much time on design.
Memberful & Circle’s Features
| Feature | Memberful | Circle |
|---|---|---|
Price + transaction fees | Three plans available on an annual subscription: Professional: $89/month + 2% transaction fees Business: $199/month + 1% transaction fees Circle Plus: Custom pricing + 0.5% transaction fees | |
Payment processing | You own your payments with Stripe Subscriptions | You own your payments with Stripe Subscriptions |
Ownership + branding | You own your content, data, and payments | You own your content, data, and payments |
Integrations + flexibility | 18 deep integrations included, including a WordPress plugin to add memberships to your existing website | 18 integrations available, including Memberful. |
Community features | Community discussions, chats, gamification, live events | |
Course features | Course builder | |
Web features | Build a membership site in Memberful or use the WordPress plugin on your existing website | Build simple websites and landing pages in Circle |
Other content types | Newsletters, blogs and publications, private podcasts, digital downloads | Simple email marketing tools |
Ease of use | Setup can take time due to deep customization | Customizations, integrations, and setup can be difficult to navigate |
Best for | Content-forward creators building a long-term membership business | Community-forward creators who want the convenience of an all-in-one platform |
Why creators and community builders switch from Circle to Memberful
While some creators love managing their communities on Circle, they want a more powerful way to manage subscriptions and memberships. In fact, some creators integrate Memberful with Circle to get the best of both worlds.
Membership capabilities
While some creators love managing their communities on Circle, they want a more powerful way to manage subscriptions and memberships. In fact, some creators integrate Memberful with Circle to get the best of both worlds.
Platform dependency
All-in-one platforms can make adding new features easy, but don’t leave much room for flexibility. Switching from Circle to Memberful lets you build robust memberships without relying on one platform for everything.
Growing beyond community
Technical limitations
Reviews mention that Circle’s backend is difficult to navigate and customizations are limited. Memberful makes it easier for creators to build fully-owned, flexible memberships without limitations, with human support available at every step.
“Memberful is a great platform for managing memberships, allowing seamless integration with our existing website.
Jeff at
Sports Business Ventures
Memberful sets the foundation for strong communities
Read more customer storiesThe Starling Club
Jamie Beck cultivates community for creatives and artists. Explore the community
The Club
Molly Baz brings foodies together with exclusive recipes in The Club. Read her story
OT Potential
Sarah Lyon’s community helps OTs share knowledge and support their patients. Read their story
Creators trust Memberful to monetize their content and grow their communities
How to migrate from Circle to Memberful
Your memberships will likely look a little different when you make the switch from Circle to Memberful. Connect with your community and let them know what changes they can expect.
Talk to your community
Your memberships will likely look a little different when you make the switch from Circle to Memberful. Connect with your community and let them know what changes they can expect.
Schedule your migration
Once you’re ready to make the move, schedule your migration 1 to 3 days ahead of time. The migration typically takes between 1 and 2 hours.
Migrate Stripe data
Memberful uses Stripe to process payments, just like Circle does. You’ll use Stripe to migrate your members and subscriptions into Memberful.
We’ve got your back
Memberful’s support team is here to answer any questions you have during your migration, and whenever you need us after that, too.
Frequently asked questions
Memberful is free to try for as long as you like, so you can get into the details.
See more comparisons
Community
Memberful vs. Mighty Networks
Two popular ways to run a paid community, built differently. Compare pricing, ownership, and where your members actually live.
Community
Memberful vs. LaunchPass
Memberful and LaunchPass help set up and manage community memberships, but what tool matches what you need?
Digital Products
Memberful vs. Whop
Two options for earning income from the community you’re building. Compare pricing, features, and the benefits of owning your audience.